B. Riley Wealth Tax Services
★★★★★ (154 reviews)484 Temple Hill Rd Suite 106, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 567-5100
Website: brileyfin.com/capabilities/wealth/tax-services
Hours: {"Friday":["8:30 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["8:30 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["8:30 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["8:30 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["8:30 AM–5 PM"]}
H&R Block
★★★★½ (84 reviews)356 Windsor Hwy #32, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 561-3604
Website: www.hrblock.com/tax-office-near-me/new-york/new-windsor/29768/?otppartnerid=9308&campaignid=pw_mcm_9308_9762&utm_medium=local
Hours: {}
Mi Casa Business Services LLC
★★★★★ (27 reviews)339 Blooming Grove Turnpike Suite 5, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 863-9564
Website: micasabusiness.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
★★☆☆☆ (14 reviews)300 Commerce Dr, New Windsor, NY 12553
(800) 829-1040
Website: www.irs.gov
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Rossi Jerome CPA
★★★★★ (3 reviews)314 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 562-0802
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
TaxDebt.com
★★★★★ (2 reviews)484 Temple Hill Rd Suite 106, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 477-3328
Website: taxdebt.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–6 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–6 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–6 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–6 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–6 PM"]}
ALR Accounting Service LLC
★★★★★ (2 reviews)189 Riley Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 219-1639
Website: www.alraccountingservice.com
Hours: {}
Moeller Richard K CPA
★★★★★ (2 reviews)276 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 787-0560
Hours: {}
Ways & Means Inc
★★★★★ (1 reviews)815 Blooming Grove Turnpike # 202, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 562-6070
Hours: {}
Tax Solutions By Elizabeth LLC
843 Union Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 549-8597
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Sunday":["12–4 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
New Windsor Receiver of Taxes
555 Union Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 563-4627
Website: newwindsor-ny.gov/Officials-Departments/Receiver-of-Taxes
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–4:45 PM"]}
About Tax Preparers in New Windsor, NY
Finding a qualified tax preparer in New Windsor, New York, can make a significant difference during tax season. As a town with a mix of residential communities, local retail businesses, and proximity to Stewart International Airport, many residents face unique tax situations—from self-employment income to investment properties. A local preparer understands New York state tax laws and can help you navigate deductions specific to your area.
Whether you’re a small business owner on Route 32 or a remote worker living near the Hudson River, a tax professional can save you time and reduce errors. They can also help with year-round planning, estimated tax payments, or responding to IRS notices. Choosing someone familiar with the local economy ensures your return reflects the full picture of your financial life.
Before selecting a preparer, verify their credentials and check for any complaints with the Better Business Bureau. A good fit will listen to your needs and explain things clearly. Use BeforeTaxUSA.com to compare qualified professionals in New Windsor and find the right match for your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What qualifications should a tax preparer have?
At minimum, a paid tax preparer must have an IRS-issued PTIN. Look for additional credentials like Enrolled Agent (EA) status, CPA license, or completion of the IRS Annual Filing Season Program. These indicate higher levels of training and accountability.
How much does tax preparation cost?
Simple individual returns (W-2 income only) typically cost $100-$300. Returns with itemized deductions, self-employment income, or rental properties can cost $300-$800 or more. Always ask for a fee estimate upfront before committing.
What documents do I need to bring to my tax preparer?
Bring all W-2s, 1099 forms, records of deductible expenses, last year's tax return, Social Security numbers for all family members, bank account information for direct deposit, and any IRS correspondence you have received.
BeforeTaxUSA.com is a free informational directory. Listings are compiled from publicly available data and do not constitute an endorsement or recommendation. Verify credentials, licensing, and reviews independently before engaging any professional. Listings appear in no particular order unless otherwise noted.
Business owners: to update or remove a listing, email info@beforetaxusa.com.