H&R Block
★★★★½ (141 reviews)603 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 665-2971
Website: www.hrblock.com/tax-office-near-me/new-york/bay-shore/31180/?otppartnerid=9308&campaignid=pw_mcm_9308_9762&utm_medium=local
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–2 PM"],"Monday":["Closed"],"Saturday":["10 AM–4 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["Closed"],"Tuesday":["2–7 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–4 PM"]}
LD Tax Pro Inc
★★★★★ (123 reviews)1389 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-7677
Hours: {"Friday":["Closed"],"Monday":["10 AM–2 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["10 AM–2 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–2 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–2 PM"]}
Jackson Hewitt Tax Service
★★★★½ (99 reviews)79 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 206-1515
Website: office.jacksonhewitt.com/tax-preparation-services-locations/en/ny/bay-shore/79-howells-rd/15412?utm_source=google&utm_medium=local&utm_campaign=local&utm_content=15412
Hours: {}
D&R Agencies
★★★★★ (66 reviews)1 W Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 966-4133
Website: www.dragencies.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["Closed"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Tait's Tax Service INC
★★★★★ (63 reviews)94W W Main St Suite 205, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 825-2626
Website: taitstaxservice.com
Hours: {"Friday":["Closed"],"Monday":["10 AM–3:30 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["10 AM–3:30 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–3:30 PM"],"Wednesday":["Closed"]}
MG Income Tax Service
★★★★★ (42 reviews)1774 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 873-4956
Hours: {"Friday":["10 AM–8 PM"],"Monday":["10 AM–4 PM"],"Saturday":["9 AM–4 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["10 AM–8 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–8 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–8 PM"]}
Proficient Consulting Services Inc
★★★★½ (23 reviews)1656 5th Ave Suite D, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-4940
Website: www.proficientsvcs.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Bookwise Business Solutions
★★★★★ (21 reviews)160 Howells Rd Ste 28, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(516) 493-2946
Website: bookwiseservices.com
Hours: {"Friday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["10 AM–6 PM"],"Saturday":["12–4 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–5 PM"]}
Ketty S Robles Accounting
★★★★☆ (16 reviews)609A E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 954-5090
Website: kettyrobles.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Saturday":["10 AM–4 PM"],"Sunday":["2–6 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–7 PM"]}
Q-RISE Tax + Accounting & Business Services - Best Income Tax Return Filing
★★★★★ (11 reviews)1394 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-9200
Website: taxfilingpros.com
Hours: {"Friday":["11 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["11 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["11 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["11 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["11 AM–5 PM"]}
On-The-Go-Bookkeeping & Notary
★★★★☆ (10 reviews)6 Sampson St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 520-1628
Website: on-the-go-bookeeping.com
Hours: {"Friday":["Open 24 hours"],"Monday":["Open 24 hours"],"Saturday":["Open 24 hours"],"Sunday":["Open 24 hours"],"Thursday":["Open 24 hours"],"Tuesday":["Open 24 hours"],"Wednesday":["Open 24 hours"]}
M&D Accounting Multiservice Associates, LLC
★★★★★ (7 reviews)41 Abbott Pl, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(646) 468-3486
Website: www.md-accountingmultiservice.com
Hours: {"Friday":["10 AM–6 PM"],"Monday":["10 AM–6 PM"],"Saturday":["10 AM–4 PM"],"Sunday":["10 AM–4 PM"],"Thursday":["10 AM–6 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–6 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–6 PM"]}
Justin D. Restmeyer CPA
★★★★★ (7 reviews)1320 N Windsor Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 970-4929
Website: justinrestmeyercpa.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Taxseguros
★★★☆☆ (8 reviews)1663 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 273-3000
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Saturday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Sunday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–9 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–9 PM"]}
Fast Tax
★★★☆☆ (6 reviews)1557 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1055
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Saturday":["9:30 AM–3 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–7 PM"]}
MULTISERVICES & TAX SERVICES PORRAS LLC
★★★★★ (3 reviews)121 King St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 575-5684
Hours: {"Friday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["8 AM–5 PM"]}
Valia LLC
★★★★★ (3 reviews)45 5th Ave Unit 1, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(934) 888-6053
Website: valiallc.com
Hours: {"Friday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["10 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["10 AM–5 PM"]}
Salvi Multiservice LLC
★★★★★ (3 reviews)1658 N Gardiner Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 935-2048
Hours: {"Friday":["5–10:30 PM"],"Monday":["5–10 PM"],"Saturday":["5–10 PM"],"Sunday":["5–10 PM"],"Thursday":["5–10 PM"],"Tuesday":["5–10 PM"],"Wednesday":["5–10 PM"]}
Christopher Hernandez, CPA
★★★½☆ (3 reviews)1340 Lombardy Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 766-6405
Website: www.citysearch.com/profile/666033834/bay_shore_ny/christopher_hernandez_cpa.html
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
Continental Service taxes
★★★★★ (1 reviews)1805 5th Ave Suite 5, Second Floor, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 952-1997
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Saturday":["9 AM–4 PM"],"Sunday":["9 AM–4 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–7 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–7 PM"]}
TC Randello & Associates
★★★★★ (1 reviews)260 W Main St Suite #15, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-4322
Website: www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100089796920607
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}
AMC TAX SERVICES
★★★★★ (1 reviews)1821B 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 273-4818
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Saturday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Sunday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Thursday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–10 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–10 PM"]}
Chinchilla Tax Services LLC
1766 Stein Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 245-8219
Hours: {}
About Tax Preparers in Bay Shore, NY
Bay Shore, New York, is home to a diverse mix of small businesses, retail shops, and maritime industries along the Great South Bay. With its busy Main Street and growing residential community, many residents face unique tax situations—from self-employment income to investment properties near the waterfront. A local tax preparer familiar with New York State and Suffolk County regulations can help navigate these complexities without the guesswork.
Whether you’re a freelancer managing quarterly estimated taxes or a family claiming education credits, a qualified tax preparer in Bay Shore ensures your return is accurate and complete. They stay current on local tax law changes, including any pandemic-era relief programs still affecting small businesses. This saves you time and reduces the risk of audits or missed deductions.
When searching for a tax professional on BeforeTaxUSA.com, look for preparers who specialize in your specific needs—such as real estate, gig economy work, or multi-state filings. A good fit will offer clear communication and a straightforward fee structure, helping you file with confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
What qualifications should a tax preparer have?
At minimum, a paid tax preparer must have an IRS-issued PTIN. Look for additional credentials like Enrolled Agent (EA) status, CPA license, or completion of the IRS Annual Filing Season Program. These indicate higher levels of training and accountability.
How much does tax preparation cost?
Simple individual returns (W-2 income only) typically cost $100-$300. Returns with itemized deductions, self-employment income, or rental properties can cost $300-$800 or more. Always ask for a fee estimate upfront before committing.
What documents do I need to bring to my tax preparer?
Bring all W-2s, 1099 forms, records of deductible expenses, last year's tax return, Social Security numbers for all family members, bank account information for direct deposit, and any IRS correspondence you have received.
BeforeTaxUSA.com is a free informational directory. Listings are compiled from publicly available data and do not constitute an endorsement or recommendation. Verify credentials, licensing, and reviews independently before engaging any professional. Listings appear in no particular order unless otherwise noted.
Business owners: to update or remove a listing, email info@beforetaxusa.com.